History has handed us countless innovations, and just as many reasons to resist them. Below is an argument against progress with a few blanks in it. Pick a number from 1 to 10 to fill them in. Then pick another.
We are told to welcome A as progress. Its advocates promise that everything will be faster and easier, and anyone who doubts them is called afraid of change. But easier has never meant better. Somewhere along the way we decided that saving time mattered more than the skill and effort that give work its meaning.
Consider the B who spent years mastering their craft, only to watch that expertise lose its worth to anyone who wants the job done faster and cheaper. We are trading skill for convenience and calling the trade a gift, because now anyone can produce what once had to be earned. If effort is optional, achievement doesn’t mean much.
For generations, C was how things were done. It took patience to learn, and it was handed down from old hands to young ones. With A, the result may be much the same, but nobody had to learn anything to get it. A society that cares only about the result will forget how the work was done.
Call this resistance to change if you must. Some innovations are a step backward, and some traditions deserve to be kept. We should stand up for human craftsmanship before we hand it over to the latest convenience. There was a time before A when skill and patience mattered. Perhaps we were better off then.
A is a technology. B is the people it put out of work. C is what they used to do.
For thousands of years we have asked whether the newest tool makes us less human. The trades and the tools keep changing. The argument has barely been edited.
Perhaps the oldest tradition of all is insisting that the latest invention will ruin everything the previous one made possible.
The argument may even be right. It is certainly old. If one essay can be used against 5,000 years of invention, what does that tell us about the essay?
All ten, for anyone who would like the punchline without the clicking:
Leave a Reply